Login / Logout Link

You Have to Spend Money to Make Change

Last week, my colleagues Rosanne Tollenaar, Jann Beeston and I attended CCVO’s second annual Connections Conference in Calgary. Many of the speakers at the conference, as well as the participants, spoke with frustration about a common misconception about the nonprofit/voluntary  sector:  that putting money towards administration and overhead costs somehow takes money away from the work nonprofits do, rather than make their work possible. Those in the sector know that this isn’t a new problem – organizations have long been trying to offer successful programs and services, while struggling to find money for the organizational infrastructure necessary to do so.

Sue Tomney, CEO of the YWCA of Calgary, a panelist at the conference, made a strong case for why funders should want to see administration fees in their contracts and grants to nonprofits by reframing this issue from funders’ perspectives. She described her dream funder as someone who insisted on 15% of a contract budget dedicated to administration and 10% assigned to advocacy work.

A realistic cost for administration shows the funder that the organization has the governance, policy, and financial oversight to properly manage a contract or grant. While this may sometimes be available in-kind through a board and volunteers, most organizations have costs associated with bookkeepers and financial controllers, leadership and management positions, and knowledgeable staff familiar with the specifics of internal policies and legal requirements. As well, a substantial administration budget line shows funders that staff at the organization are being paid and managed fairly, and that the organization has the appropriate people, infrastructure, and capacity to communicate with the funder, internally, and externally throughout the project. Without these things in place, a funder should be concerned about how their contract will be carried out.

Tomney included 10% advocacy as well on the basis that most funders want to make an impact on an issue or cause through their contracts and grants. For example, a funder choosing to support the YWCA on an initiative to help homeless women is likely concerned about homelessness, domestic violence, or mental illness. By requiring an organization to do advocacy work around these issues, the funder can ensure that the contract works toward eliminating the problem, rather than providing short term band-aid solutions. Eventually the funder won’t have to give money to the organization and instead will have invested in the solution(s).

Understanding Tomney’s perspective puts nonprofits in a better position to make our case to funders for why these costs are necessary. Hopefully it can open funders’ eyes to why we should all be on the same page when it comes to paying for the work required to improve our communities and change our world.

Here’s more reading on why it’s necessary to spend on administration.

 

Sam Kriviak, Program Coordinator

VA Staff Volunteer Experiences

Throughout National Volunteer Week the VA blog will be featuring the volunteer experiences of the Volunteer Alberta staff. Volunteerism comes in a variety of shapes and sizes and so does volunteer recognition. We encourage you to share with us your experiences in volunteerism – Tell us where you have volunteered and how you were recognized!

Tim

During the 2010 Edmonton Municipal Election, I volunteered for Don Iveson’s City Council re-election campaign. Councillor Iveson put an emphasis on ensuring that the volunteer experience was not only a positive one, but also downright fun. During the final week of the campaign he held volunteer events with food provided by the Eva Sweets waffle truck in the morning and Elm Café sandwiches in the afternoon. Every volunteer was invited to the election night party, which was great, but volunteer recognition was a focus throughout the whole campaign. Volunteers were also given t-shirts emblazoned with the proposed future LRT map. Don took the time to individually thank each member of his large and enthusiastic group of volunteers; and in the end, that was the best form of recognition – a sincere ‘thank you’.

Brooke

I spent a day volunteering for the cross-country phase of a June event put on by the Clearwater Valley Pony Club in Beaumont.  It was a cold and dark morning when the alarm went off; thankfully I can always hop out of bed for a horse related event.  My 5 year old daughter and I were looking forward to the day.  We showed up to a well-organized and friendly crew with free hot coffee and breakfast.  It didn’t take long for me to receive good instructions, answers to my questions and supplies (pre-packed snacks, a radio and a lawn chair).  My daughter instantly connected with the crew of kids whom she hadn’t met previously and set off aboard an ATV, smiles plastered on their faces.  After hiking out to my allotted jumps for the day, I set up camp and nestled in.  What a joy to get a front row seat to all the horse jumping action and to be involved in judging the competition. It was also a treat to learn more about running an event and to hear the discussion on the radio between the officials.  Occasionally the ATV full of children would fly by, and refill my coffee cup and ask if I needed anything.  We were very well looked after and what was a long day on the clock flew by too fast.  My daughter was given the opportunity to be a part of the group and made many new friends in the process.  I can’t wait to volunteer at the event again, it was a great group people and a wonderful experience for my daughter and I.

Cindy

I was one of 1100 volunteers for this year’s Tim Hortons Brier. The sea of blue (our jackets) was apparent everywhere you looked.  50-50 volunteers were the largest division – as there were usually 50+ people per draw. Some days had 3 draws so I’m sure the logistics were crazy!

As a 50-50 volunteer, I had different shifts, either selling tickets or helping in the count room. Selling was fun – got to walk about, chat with people, provide information, and mingle with other volunteers. In the count room, we had to quickly and efficiently file all the sellers through once the draw closed so the winner could be chosen in a timely manner.  I even got to pull a couple of the winning tickets! Chatting with the other volunteers was great fun and we even discussed how volunteering might be a great way to see the event when another city hosts it.

Overall it was a great experience. It was a long time to volunteer for – I was there for seven out of the events 10 days, including one day I did a double shift. However, we worked with super staff and the volunteer coordinators were very appreciative.

We got to show how fantastic the volunteers are in Edmonton and Alberta. Can’t complain.

Sam

My fondest volunteer experience by far was a three year stint with the radio show Adamant Eve on the campus and community radio station CJSR. I started working on the show through a Community-Service Learning (CSL) placement for a university course, but I fell in love with it and asked to stay on, eventually becoming the producer of the show a year and a half later. I can’t pinpoint what made my time there so great – I have a hard time narrowing it down. I had great mentors. I had room to be creative, to grow and advance. I got to research things that interested me, interview people that inspired me, and use my writing skills to put together scripts. I had freedom and support simultaneously. I worked with friends on live show nights, and fulfilled my introverted, perfectionist tendencies putting together our pre-recorded shows. It was the perfect mix of flexibility and challenge with a huge dose of discovery and ownership.

Usually ‘volunteer recognition’ means free cupcakes, reference letters, or parties. While I would never turn down a free cupcake, for me all of the factors that made my time at Adamant Eve amazing were volunteer recognition in and of themselves. After all, what better way to keep a volunteer than to make them happy in a fulfilling role!

Lisa

Last year, I volunteered for the 2012 IIHF World Junior Hockey Championships. As a hockey fan since birth, I was thrilled to help out. There were two specific highlights for me. As a Ceremonies volunteer, one of my duties was to help pass out a large Canadian flag for excited fans to pass it around the arena! Our volunteer team sprinted around the upper bowl of Rexall Place to keep up with the flag, to ensure it didn’t touch the ground and that it was quickly wrapped up at the end. The other major highlight was distributing the Player of the Game awards on New Year’s Eve, when Team Canada beat the United States. Being on the ice, in the middle of Rexall Place hearing the crowd drown out the Canadian anthem played was certainly something I’ll remember forever. I couldn’t believe that I got to do all these great things as a volunteer!

3 Lessons for Making Recognition Matter

With National Volunteer Week coming (April 21 – 27, 2013) I got to thinking about recognition and what it means to be recognized. I have volunteered with the Edmonton Folk Music Festival (EFMF) for the last eight years in various roles from night security to my current role as a member of the site kitchen team. The one thing that has kept me coming back to the festival year after year is the ability of event organizers to recognize all of its volunteers. Thankfully, the festival has the capacity to provide diverse recognition approaches and I understand many nonprofit organizations do not have the same capacity, but from where I sit as a volunteer, I think there are strong lessons for all organizations in what EFMF does.

Lesson #1: Recognition is continuous and happens simultaneously with retention and recruitment.

Every EFMF volunteer gets a package a couple of days before the festival starts that contains the information they need for the four festival days, as well as your crew t-shirt and I.D badge. We get a t-shirt with the new design for that year ahead of the general festival goer and we get a special badge that grants access to volunteer-only events. The badge is also a clear reminder of the diligence the festival has taken in ensuring each volunteer is screened and in the appropriate position so that I can feel confident in the abilities of the people I volunteer with, and them in me. These packages mean that recognizing volunteers is not an afterthought but rather integrated into all components of volunteer engagement.

Lesson #2: Make space for volunteering to be fun

During the festival, on the Friday, Saturday, and Sunday evenings, after the days concert has ended there are volunteer only (no exceptions) parties! The venue is smaller and there are quiet rooms for impromptu jam sessions and a large party room with live music, and the party lineup is different every night. After a long day of volunteering you are tired; you love what you do but it is still work. These parties are nothing but an unapologetic opportunity for the volunteers to have a ton of fun laughing, reminiscing, rehashing the best and worst parts of the day and getting to let it all out. These parties don’t make you anymore rested for the next day but the smiles and memories created will get you through.

Lesson #3: Say thank you in the biggest, most public way you can

Each night of the festival, just as the sun is going down, there is a lantern parade that makes its way through the crowd onto the main stage. This lantern parade is dedicated to the volunteers of the festival, and makes everyone stop and clap and say thank you. I get a little misty eyed each time because it reminds me of why I’m there. I volunteer to be part of this great festival so that those that paid to attend and those that volunteered have the best possible time. It’s great that other people care enough to say thank you. There is also a giant display on the festival grounds with the names of every single volunteer for all to see and it’s bigger than the signs the sponsors get!

These lessons aren’t ground breaking but it is important to be reminded of them nonetheless. I believe that each organization can find ways to incorporate these three lessons into their volunteer engagement approaches. As we move closer to National Volunteer Week let’s take the time to look at how we can make recognition an ever present part of volunteering in both subtle and overt ways. It’s the least we can do for the volunteers that drive communities forward.

Annand Ollivierre, Program Manager

Federal Budget Analysis

Perhaps Drache Aptowitzer LLP’s Adam Aptowitzer summed up the federal government’s Budget 2013 best when he said, “Despite bearing relatively little news for charities, this in itself is probably good news for charities.”

While the Alberta budget roared in following months of controversy, Jim Flaherty’s Budget 2013 strolled in with little fanfare. That said, critics of the budget certainly exist on both sides of the spectrum, with some complaining the government cut too much, while others are saying they didn’t cut enough.

There isn’t much in the way of new spending in the budget and many of the big announcements are just reallocations of funding.

There is no specific mention of the Canada Summer Jobs program, which is of special interest to Alberta’s nonprofits after the Summer Temporary Employment Program was cut.

For international development organizations, it is interesting to note that The Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) will now be a junior ministry under Foreign Affairs. This move is to increase efficiencies, though critics warn it opens up CIDA to more political influence. The long term effects of this decision are yet to be seen, but I expect more coverage on this issue.

Despite the attention that Bill C-458 (National Charities Week Act) drew a couple of months ago, the stretch tax credits for charitable donations are not included in this budget. What did appear was the First Time Donors Credit, a supplement to the existing charitable donations tax credit (CDTC) and would allow for an individual to receive an additional 25% tax credit on a first-time charitable donation.

Apparently to encourage young people to start donating, anyone who has not filed a charitable tax deduction since 2007 is eligible for the program. This one-time “super-credit” will bump the non-refundable tax credit of 15% percent for donations under $200 to 40% and for $200-$1000 donations from 29% to 54%.

All in all, there is nothing shocking about Federal Budget 2013. Information on other aspects of the budget can be found on the federal government website. The Globe and Mail also has an in-depth analysis.

 

Steven Kwasny, Stakeholder Relations Coordinator

Guest Blog: Volunteerism has changed – but have nonprofits changed with it?

“Volunteering is on the decline.”
“Young people are disengaged.”
“People are abandoning community.”

I heard versions of these same concerns while delivering workshops last week in three very different communities.

While on the surface many would believe these are valid issues, personally I’m not buying it.

I’m not buying it because everywhere I go, in addition to these concerns, I’m also hearing that people are hungry for a sense of community and for being connected to one another. And, despite not always being involved, they very much do want to give back to their communities.

Could it be that it isn’t people who are abandoning community, but rather, communities abandoning people?

As my good friend Ian Hill puts it, volunteering has changed but communities and nonprofit organizations haven’t always changed with them.

He’s so very right.

Hill points out that volunteering is in our DNA because it used to be obligatory and essential.

When people first settled in Canada, if they didn’t volunteer to help one another clear the land and build their homes and barns, they simply wouldn’t have survived.  If they hadn’t banded together and shared their respective resources, they wouldn’t have been able to respond to the need for roads, churches, schools, parks, and other community services.

In essence, people worked together to implement a collective vision for their community, worked side by side to complete the required activities, and shared the resulting victories. Along the way, they built relationships, trust, and ultimately — a sense of community.

Following World Wars I and II as we strove to become more civilized — or at least what we saw as being civilized — we outsourced the work, hiring other people to deliver the services and build the roads, churches, schools, and parks that used to be done by volunteers.

When it became clear that volunteering could no longer be dictated as being essential to survival, people were often shamed or “guilted” into serving their community. For instance, many of my parents’ generation were raised to feel it was part of their moral obligation to give back to their community.

Today, it seems we’ve lost the experience born of both the dictated, shared experiences of sweat equity volunteering, and of being guilted into volunteering.

Ultimately that means we’ve lost the trusted relationships cultivated by volunteering, as well as the understanding and importance of both community and community building.

The fallout of this is that we have become a pretty cynical bunch.

Since we no longer have dictated shared experiences and volunteering is no longer seen as obligatory, we’ve ended up living in communities where although we might have connections with those who share the same interests, we don’t have trusted relationships and a sense of belonging. Instead, we are asking, “Why should I be involved in my community?” and are challenging community groups to prove to us that their initiative is worth our time, talent, and treasure.

If we aren’t convinced the volunteering is worthwhile, we may be seen as being apathetic or disengaged when it is likely more about the fact that we don’t know and trust one another.

Unfortunately, the majority of community groups have failed to adjust to this reality and still believe they can dictate the experience rather than having it dictated by the user. Too often this means that while community groups have a cohort of mature volunteers, they aren’t being augmented with new recruits.

So what do we do?

Everyone who wants to engage someone as a volunteer needs to begin by investing time and energy into  building relationships — face to face, one cup of coffee at a time.  The intent is to focus on discovering and putting to work what Hill calls, the “irrational passion” within each of us, and to give the potential volunteer the choice for how it can be applied.

The world is full of educated, experienced, talented people who care about their communities, and are willing and wanting to contribute.

Citizens young and old are seeking meaningful, relevant, time-specific projects that will allow them to dictate the experience and be paid — not with money but with meaning.

 

Brenda Herchmer,

CEO of Campus for Communities of the Future
Owner of Grassroots Enterprises

 

If you are interested in contributing to the VA blog as a Guest Blogger, please contact Tim at thenderson@volunteeralberta.ab.ca

Not-for-profit Web Consulting & Digital Marketing by Adster Creative